Gold Tooth Tony's Claim this business

A Melon Google

4 weeks ago

I ordered three 12” pizzas through the Gold Tooth Tony website for nearly $75. When they arrived, the toppings had completely slid off of two and the pizzas were barely warm. The manager insisted there was nothing they could do because they “don’t handle the delivery,” despite the fact that I ordered directly through their website and wasn’t given any delivery options to choose from. They finally agreed to issue a refund—but only if I drove to the restaurant so they could process it in person which I believe was a tactic to avoid the refund. Aside from the bad experience, the pizza was not worth $75. Too many great pizza options in Montrose to waste time with this one!

Ryan Diefenderferon Google

6 months ago

This place is a dive with damn good pizzas and a huge selection of solid beer for great prices. Happy hour deals on drinks are great. Pizzas very reasonably priced. They’ve got all kinds of weekly events, from comedy shows to D & D and pottery. They’ve nailed the English pub vibe. Plenty of pool tables and arcade games.

Michael Munizon Google

9 months ago

If you read my review about the Gold Tooth Tony's Heights location, you found a pretty glowing one. This one, not so much. So the first and foremost thing to know about the Gold Tooth Tony's Montrose location is that it's inside of Rudyard's. And there is NO way of knowing that from the exterior. I myself only found out from Yelp reviews. So, that actually plays into the most important aspect of this review. See, when it's a standalone restaurant, you have employees that represent that company and (ideally) deliver excellent customer service. Here, it's different. You order from the bartenders, who obviously work for the bar and not Gold Tooth Tony's directly. I went on Halloween afternoon right after work so it's not like the place was packed. And I only went here instead of the Heights since it was so much closer. I stood at the bar for literally 5 minutes as a bartender did...well something...at the register before telling me the lady next to her would help me. And that took another few minutes. So I had already spent nearly 10 minutes here without any help and it didn't seem like they would care if I left or not (I almost did). My order was taken by the 2nd bartender who was at least a little nicer (and acknowledged my existence unlike the first one!) I ordered a Detroit Style pizza, a 12" Houston style, and a Caesar Salad. At no point was I asked if it was for there or to-go, but one would assume a guy wouldn't sit there and eat all that food there by himself...unless I just look THAT depressed or like I hate myself that much?? So the first bartender (the one who had originally ignored me) brought out the salad to the table where I waited and I had to tell her that it was a to-go order. She seemed upset, even though, like I said, NO ONE had asked me beforehand. And she was not even a little upset, she was glaring like I had just shot her dog and walked over its cadaver Allen-Iverson-over-Ty-Lue style. But I digress. In total, I waited about 35 minutes for the order, which I actually think is about right for 2 pizzas without calling ahead. I was glad to get my food as it was not a remotely cordial atmosphere. But for me, that's a big bummer part of it. You look forward to getting pizza for a night in with some fun horror movies (especially on Halloween!) and it shouldn't be started out with unfriendly, unwelcoming service. The good news? The pizza was great. The one I got was the Detroit Hunger Force and it was absolutely fantastic. My girlfriend had done a build-your-own with ricotta, sausage, onions, and bacon. Even the Caesar was spectacular. So, yes, the food (which is the most important thing) is just as great as it is at the Heights location. But the service leaves A LOT to be desired and that is also a significant part of the overall dining experience. Yes, I get that a bar makes money from the alcohol sales, but I'm sure lots of other people are like me who are just there for the food and want to be valued as customers equally (especially when dropping over $60 for a meal, 3 items, at that). I probably wouldn't go back here and hope this helps other potential customers to level set on expectations when it comes to the service, which falls flat.

Tamara Hon Google

4 months ago

The pizza itself has good flavor, the crust is good. The regular pizza is good. As a native Detroiter, the Detroit Style pepperoni pizza isn’t it. :( I wanted to like it, and I guess I should’ve known from the pics. I thought the sauce on top was an add-on but no that’s the way a regular pizza comes. We don’t put sauce on the very top of our pizzas. That’s Chicago. Good pizza overall though!

d kendzon Google

a year ago

One of the coolest places to unwind after a stressful week at work. Mackenzie hooked us up with a great table but honestly any would have been fine! Awesome experience and we will be back. By the way, their Detroit Pizza rocks!